Professionals Increase Customer Satisfaction by Saying "No" to Customer Requests

How would you define the word "professional"?

Someone with specialized knowledge? Someone with rich experience who can respond flexibly?

For me, a professional had the image of "someone with advanced skills who can handle difficult requests and seemingly impossible tasks."

Taking on projects that everyone thinks are absolutely impossible and making them successful. Someone who never says "can't do it" in any situation--that's a professional.

However, recently, I've revised my perception: "saying yes to everything isn't what makes someone a professional."

Because there are situations where saying "no" to a customer's wishes is necessary for customer satisfaction.

When Following the Customer's Wishes Was Called a "Failure"

Planning a major remodel soon, I've recently been hooked on watching interior design and housing videos. Particularly interesting are videos about regrets with custom-built homes.
A house--one of the most expensive purchases in life. It's a place you live every day, and you want to create an ideal space packed with your dreams.
However, even with a house packed with all your dreams, when you actually live in it, "this isn't what I expected..." can happen.
While that's unavoidable, I often think, "No, come on, the contractor should have warned them about that...?"
For example, a house where the children's room has three downlights in a row, resulting in triple shadows that make it hard to concentrate on studying.
A house where, as a result of choosing white-colored flooring because "I want a bright room!", their long hair and black dog fur stand out noticeably and bother them.
Couldn't a professional have foreseen these things to some extent when building the house? Why didn't they properly communicate such disadvantages during the consultation phase?
Of course, both the triple downlights and the white-colored flooring were requested by the customer themselves, and the contractor made the house exactly as requested, so it's not wrong.
But whether it benefited the customer or whether they're satisfied is a separate matter.


画像16.png

The Ideal House, Yet... Why They Were Dissatisfied

Actually, I've experienced this too.
When my parents decided to build a house when I was in middle school, they showed me the floor plan saying, "We're planning to make it like this, what do you think?" and I tilted my head at the fact that my room was square.
"Doesn't a square room seem kind of hard to use? I'd have space in the middle." "You think so?" "Yeah, my current room is rectangular, and rooms are normally rectangular, aren't they? I don't want a square room."
My parents respected my opinion and made my brother's room square as planned, while making my room rectangular. My wish was granted.
But however.
After completion, I deeply regretted: "Big brother's room feels overwhelmingly more spacious!! I should have had a square room too!!"
Simply I had more stuff, but my brother's room felt cleaner and more spacious. In fact, his room was larger.
Moreover, as a result of making my room rectangular, my parents' bedroom became smaller, and the dead space was apparently turned into a closet as storage.
Learning this, I thought from the bottom of my heart, "If it was going to affect so many things, I should have been fine with a square room..."
It was none other than me who said I didn't want a square room. And my parents and the contractor went to the trouble of reconsidering the floor plan and even made my parents' bedroom smaller to fulfill that wish.
But as a result, I'm not that satisfied--rather, I'm thinking, "I'm envious of big brother's square room."
Selfish as it may be, I can't help thinking: rather than respecting the words of a middle schooler, I wish the contractor had said, "If you simulate placing furniture, it'll look like this and there's no problem. The square room is more spacious..."


画像17.png

What Does the Customer Really Want?

There's a saying: "A person who comes to buy a drill doesn't want a drill--they want a 'hole.'"
The drill is the means; the purpose is to make a hole. If the purpose can be achieved, the means doesn't have to be a drill. If you're a professional, you should discern what the customer really wants and needs, and provide it.
That's what it means.
What I wanted was a comfortable room.
"Why didn't I want a square room?" Simply because I'd never lived in a square room and couldn't imagine it = I was anxious about whether it would be a comfortable room. If the square room would be comfortable, there would have been no problem.
To reiterate, I myself hoped for a rectangular room, and they made a rectangular room as I wished, so there's no complaint about the work itself.
However, if they had gone one step further and discussed together what goal the statement "I want it rectangular" was actually aiming to achieve, the outcome might have been different.


画像18.png

The Courage to Say "No" to Customer Wishes

The fundamental premise is to fulfill the customer's wishes to the maximum extent. However, by saying "no" to a customer's wishes, you can conversely increase their satisfaction.
Let me give some examples using custom-built homes.
A woman had dreamed of a house with a double-height ceiling since she was little, and requested one first thing for her custom home.
However, having a double-height ceiling would mean one less room on the second floor, so they couldn't make rooms for two children, and the stairs would become narrow and steep, making it hard to bring large furniture to the second floor.
So the architect confirmed again why she wanted the double-height ceiling, and it turned out that because her family home was old with low ceilings, she really wanted a bright living room full of openness.
"In that case," they stopped the double-height ceiling, made the ceiling slightly higher, and adjusted the floor plan so that a large window would catch your eye when entering the room.
As a result, this woman gave up her long-held dream of a double-height ceiling, but was convinced that "if I'm actually living here, this is more practical than a double-height ceiling," and is now very satisfied with her bright and spacious living room.
As another example, a man hoped to create a large window on the staircase so sunlight would stream in.
The contractor told him, "The more windows you have, the colder it gets in winter. Because this is an area with heavy snowfall, I don't recommend a window there", which dissapointed him.
The reason he wanted a large window on the staircase was similar to the woman mentioned earlier--because the staircase at his nearby family home was dark and cold, he thought if he made the window bigger, it would be brighter and warmer with sunlight streaming in.
Still, even with a window, the winter snow would keep the sunlight out, and the cold would seep in through the glass. So really, what's the advantage of having a window at all?
So they installed more lighting on the staircase with motion sensors and adjusted the floor plan to make heating more effective, thereby realizing "bright and warm stairs."
In both these examples, they rejected the customer's wishes, but ultimately benefited the customer and led to high satisfaction.
Making the customer's wishes come true isn't the only job of a professional. If you do as told but they're not satisfied, it's meaningless.


Professionals Fulfill Customer Wishes Through Comprehensive Judgment

Of course, it's better to respond to customer wishes as much as possible.
However, customers are often not professionals, and sometimes decide on request details for vague reasons like "I kind of want it this way" or "this seems better."
As a result, as in the custom home examples, making the house as wished can result in it not becoming the ideal house.
So taking the stated wishes as-is and incorporating everything isn't always the best approach.
"I did exactly what the customer said, but instead of being satisfied, they said it was a 'failure'"--while unreasonable, it can't be helped. The customer isn't a "professional" in that field.
That's precisely why professionals must judge whether the customer in front of them really wants a drill, or actually wants a hole.
If they want a hole, it may be better in some cases to reject the wish and propose a different means, saying "it's technically possible, but you shouldn't do that" or "if you want to do that, there's also this method."
Understanding the customer's wishes and then comprehensively considering and saying "no" to some parts is an important skill for professionals.
And after saying "no," understanding the essence of the customer's wishes and being able to provide something with higher satisfaction--I think that's where professionals show their skills.

Shion Amemiya

Freelance writer based in Germany. Contributor to Yahoo! News Japan, Toyo Keizai Online, Gendai Business, and HuffPost Japan. Author of “Japanese and Germans: Not So Different After All” (Shinchosha Publishing).