Personal Attachment vs. Commercial Success: The Eternal Conflict in Creative Work

A Creator's Attachment Can Sometimes Destroy the Product - A Story of Experiencing the Eternal Conflict in Creative Work

As I've written here many times (perhaps annoyingly so), I'm currently making a CD.

Several troubles occurred in the process, and it's taking longer than I initially thought, but I learned--or rather, realized--something important there.


My main job is writing columns, which is a kind of "creative work."

Writing music is also a form of creation.


However, what I could do in my job, what I'd been doing naturally all along, I had completely forgotten in the context of music.


画像2.png

A World I Never Properly Studied

To be frank, I've never studied "composition" academically.


I only have what I "sort of" learned at a music school when I was little, and the experience of listening to various kinds of music since then. I thought "roughly, this is how it goes," and there was a part of me that was overconfident, thinking "Music is free, right?!"

Even so, the recording progressed to some extent, but troubles occurred, and because of them, I reached my breaking point.


"This won't be sellable, but I don't know what to do."


I don't have connections in the industry either, and when I was at a loss, one senior came to mind. I knew he was someone I would normally hesitate to reach out to, but I had no other option. So, I mustered up my courage and contacted him.

At first, I received some harsh feedback, but after a series of discussions, I decided to scrap what I had and ask him to handle everything - from arranging to finishing the track.


画像3.png

"Being Free" Isn't Good Enough

The first thing that arrived from the senior was the arranged audio for the first song. My impression after listening was simply:


"This is amazing."


I can be kind of contrary sometimes -- I like to do things in a tricky or unconventional way, but he had organized the song including that intent. However, for just one part, the guitar solo, I thought "I'd prefer a bit higher register..." and when I conveyed this, I received this guidance: "That'll cost extra, you know? Put aside small obsessions and try to grasp the song as a whole."

Of course, from the listener's perspective, they perceive the song as a whole rather than analyzing the range within those eight bars. That's absolutely right. Honestly, this request was my "preference."

Even so, I felt I couldn't provide something to others that I wasn't satisfied with, so I asked for the guitar solo to be re-recorded. The senior also quickly created a new melody, saying "If it's this extent."


That was fine up to that point, but then came the next song. "Music should be free. Besides, this time I'm doing this as a hobby." With such naive feelings, I had created a song that certainly didn't have the form of a typical song.
About this too, I was told: "This is just you composing purely the way you want, but it doesn't really take the shape of a proper piece. People won't want to listen to it like this, you know?"

Hearing this, I thought: I see, I need to change my way of thinking here. I also realized I had forgotten the most important thing.


画像4.png

The Most Important Thing I Had Forgotten

It's true that this project is, in a sense, an extension of my personal hobby, and for that reason, I've paid a considerable portion of the production costs out of my own pocket. However, I can't afford to give it away for free in the end. Even if it's just one or two copies, I intend to "sell" it.

When I thought about it calmly, I realized I was in self-contradiction. Even if I were truly giving it away for free, honestly, I have the desire for people to know my sound and songs through this CD.

In that case, shouldn't I make "an effort to be heard"? From the conversation with my senior, I felt this from the bottom of my heart.


My senior's advice was precise: "Looking at the sheet music and such, I understand what you're thinking, but you're not a celebrity or anything, right? So first, to get people to know you, you have to think about listenability."

That's right. Strangely enough, I believe that if you have something to convey, you must first make an effort to get people to watch or read it, using easy-to-understand visuals, or writing easy-to-read scripts, for example. That's how I approached writing scripts for TV stations back then, and it's why I continue to write columns today.


I had completely forgotten that fundamental principle.


"If you obsess too much over small things, you'll destroy the song, so think about the whole. You've written some good phrases too."


With those words from my senior, I remembered what I had forgotten. Even though it's an extension of a hobby, I do want people to listen. If that's the case, I must make such efforts.

I Had a Bit of Rebellious Spirit, But...

This senior is someone who has arranged songs for prominent artists and understands "what sells." I must confess. Rudely, I was somewhat critical of him, wondering whether it was right to create songs that would sell purely on a theoretical basis.

However, as long as we think even 1% "I want people to listen," I cannot separate myself from that theory. No matter how many small obsessions I try to pack in, if it isn't first listened by people, nothing begins. That's exactly right. The senior is doing music as a job, so he is properly thinking about what will work in distribution.


However, this makes me think again: If listeners don't care about the details anyway, couldn't I rather "quietly" embed my obsessions there?

Even if it's a small self-satisfaction, isn't it rude to deliver something to the audience that I'm not satisfied with? I also think this.

Even if it's an obsession too minute to be conveyed to anyone, there was also a part of me that wanted to gain satisfaction somewhere.


That said, if that "obsession" lacks harmony with the whole and destroys the overall work..., my head was spinning quite a bit.


画像5.png

Perhaps "Who You Create With" Is Important

Well, I still don't have an answer to this question within myself. However, I'm now convinced that while "obsessions" are fine, they "shouldn't lack harmony with the whole and destroy things."


So what should be the compromise point?

Perhaps satisfaction increases when it's collaborative work with "someone who understands you." If you can filter your particular preferences through someone's sensibility, so that even if the form changes a little, it turns into something that makes you nod and say, "Yes! That's exactly what I wanted to do!"--then that would be ideal.


I was moved by how my senior's arrangement kept the atmosphere of the song while making it more compact -- even though he had initially criticized it, saying, "What kind of opening is this?"

If I had been denied from the start with "What kind of opening is this, do we need this intro? We don't. I'm cutting it," only dissatisfaction would have remained. In fact, they almost said that, but I firmly explained my intent.

Then in the end, he understood that "obsession." And he made it even cooler.

Rather than just silently following along, properly conveying my intent--I came to think that's what I, as an amateur, should do.

Having the words to properly convey things is also important. No, this might be the most important thing.

Someone you can communicate well with, someone who "gets it" is precious. I'm now strongly feeling firsthand that creative work cannot be completed alone.

Of course, eventually I'd like to have the knowledge and skills to complete things on my own, but it seems I'm not yet at that stage.

Sayaka Shimizu

After graduating from the Faculty of Science at Kyoto University in 2002, She worked mainly as a news reporter at TBS. She covered a wide range of topics including incidents, accidents, and technology as a reporter in the Social Affairs Department, and various markets and industries as a reporter in the Economics Department before going freelance. She has contributed to many media outlets based on his reporting experience and analysis of various statistics.